Home / Resources / Strategy library / Gap fill

Strategy library · Education only

Gap fill: trade back to yesterday's close, with the stop set by the first bar.

Futures trade overnight, so the gap is measured between two fixed times: the 9:30 ET open and the prior 16:00 ET close. When the first 5-minute bar leaves the gap open, the trade goes back toward that close. Here are the rules, two real MNQ sessions, and why the stop changes size every day.

Unlocked. Your link is on its way by email. Jump to the full breakdown ↓

The full breakdown · free with your email

Unlock the full gap fill breakdown

The rule card, a real MNQ gap that filled in fifteen minutes, a real one that never filled, and how a stop that changes every day fits prop firm rules. The free overview is below; we also email you the link, so it is one tap away next time.

Adults only: you must be 18 or older to sign up. Futures trading carries substantial risk of loss.

What is a gap in futures?

A gap is the distance between where the market opens and where it closed the session before. Stocks stop trading overnight, so their gap is easy to see. Nasdaq futures trade almost around the clock, so "the gap" has to be defined before it means anything. On this page it is the regular session's open, 9:30 ET, against the prior regular session's close at 16:00 ET. Price moved between those two times while the overnight session traded; the gap is how far.

A gap fill is price trading back to that prior close during the next session. Traders watch it because the prior close is a level everyone can see, and because a gap that opens on thin overnight trading sometimes gets taken back once the full session starts.

What is the gap fill strategy?

The version on this page fades the gap. It waits for the first 5-minute bar of the session to close, and if the gap is still open, it trades back toward the prior close: short after a gap up, long after a gap down. The stop goes one tick past the first bar's far end, and the target is the prior close itself. If the gap has not filled by 12:00 ET, the trade is closed.

It is close in spirit to the VWAP mean reversion card, which also trades back toward a level, and the opposite of the opening drive, which goes with a strong first half hour instead of against it.

Illustration, not market data: the prior session closes, the market trades overnight, and the next regular session opens higher, leaving a gap. The first 5-minute bar closes with the gap still open; the short is at its close, the stop one tick over that bar's high, and the target is the prior 16:00 ET close, which price trades back to.
Fade the gap back to the prior close. The gap is the 9:30 ET open against the prior 16:00 ET close. If the first 5-minute bar leaves it open, the trade goes back toward that close, with the stop one tick past the first bar. Illustration, not market data.

The idea in five lines

  • The gap: the 9:30 ET open minus the prior session's 16:00 ET close. Trade it only if it is 25 to 200 points.
  • Setup: the first 5-minute bar (9:30) closes without having traded back to the prior close.
  • Entry and stop: that bar's close, toward the prior close; the stop one tick past the bar's high (gap up) or low (gap down), at least 10 points away.
  • Target: the prior close. No trade if the target is closer than the stop.
  • Limits: one trade a day; out at 12:00 ET if neither stop nor target has been reached.

Each choice changes the strategy. The gap could be measured from the CME settlement price, the entry could be the open itself, the time exit could be later. We teach this version as a worked example of the rules; that is not evidence it is profitable.

Why it is hard to trade inside a prop account

A gap fill trade stands against the opening move. Some days the move fades and the gap fills inside fifteen minutes. Other days it is the start of a trend and never comes back. On the failed MNQ session in the full breakdown, the gap was 175 points, price never got within 119 points of the prior close all day, and the stop was 80.5 points away because the first bar was wide. The stop comes from the first bar, so its size changes every day; a fixed contract count turns the wide days into the big losses.

Timeline of the rule card: the first 5-minute bar runs from 9:30 to 9:35 ET; if the gap is still open, the entry is at its close, 9:35; the trade then runs to its stop or to the prior close until 12:00 ET, the time exit. One trade a day, and only gaps of 25 to 200 points.
The rule card on the clock. Wait for the 9:30 bar to close, enter at 9:35 if the gap is still open, and exit at 12:00 if neither the stop nor the prior close has traded; one trade a day.

What is in the full breakdown

  • The rule cardThe exact gap definition, size filter, entry, stop, target and time rules, written so you could code them.
  • A real session where it workedMNQ, 28 Oct 2026, 5-minute chart: a 116-point gap up, a short at the first bar's close and the gap filled on the 9:45 bar.
  • A real session where it failedMNQ, 6 Oct 2026: a 175-point gap up that kept going, stopped at 10:05 on an 80.5-point stop.
  • Prop-rule fitSizing a stop that changes every day, the daily loss limit, consistency and close-out time, worked in numbers.
  • A test-it-yourself planHow to backtest and stress-test it before it costs you an evaluation.

The full breakdown · free with your email

Gap fill: rules, real charts, prop-rule fit

Preview below. Unlock it at the top of the page ↑ and it opens here.

1. The rule card

Teaching example · not a recommendation

Gap fill, regular-session open vs prior close, 5-minute bars

  1. Chart. 5-minute bars of the regular session, from 9:30 ET.
  2. Prior close. The close of the prior session's 15:55 bar, which ends at 16:00 ET. Futures keep trading after that; those bars don't count.
  3. The gap. Today's 9:30 open minus the prior close. Positive is a gap up, negative a gap down.
  4. Size filter. Trade only if the gap is at least 25 and at most 200 points.
  5. Setup. The 9:30 bar closes without having traded back to the prior close. If it already touched it, the gap is filled and there is no trade.
  6. Entry. The close of the 9:30 bar, toward the prior close: short after a gap up, long after a gap down.
  7. Stop. One tick (0.25) past the 9:30 bar's high (short) or low (long). At least 10 points from the entry.
  8. Target. The prior close. If it is closer to the entry than the stop is, there is no trade. If the stop and the target both trade in one bar, the stop counts.
  9. Time exit. If neither has traded by 12:00 ET, exit at the close of the 11:55 bar.
  10. Limits. One trade a day.
  11. Size. Contracts = the money you allow per trade ÷ (stop distance in points × the contract's point value), rounded down. If one contract is already more than you allow, there is no trade.

Rules 2 and 3 are what make it a futures gap. Because the market trades overnight, the gap has to be measured between two fixed times, and this card uses the stock market's hours: 16:00 and 9:30 ET. Rule 7 is why the stop changes every day: it comes from the first bar, which was 65.5 points tall on 28 October and 91.75 on 6 October. Point values come from CME Group's contract specs: MNQ is $2 a point, NQ $20. Our examples use micros.

2. A session where the rules worked

Real chartSelected example, chosen to show the rulesTarget

MNQ 5-minute chart, 27 October 2026 from 15:20 ET to 28 October 10:35 ET: the prior close at 29,813.50, a 9:30 open at 29,929.50, 116 points higher; the 9:30 bar closes at 29,930.75, a short there with the stop at 29,953.00, one tick over the bar's high; the 9:45 bar trades to 29,770.25, through the prior close, and the gap is filled
MNQ (Dec 2026) · 5-minute · 27–28 Oct 2026, ET · Chart: TradingView (snapshot; levels and labels marked by Tarrow Futures). A past session, selected to show the rules, not a typical result.
StepWhat the chart showsNumber
Prior close27 Oct, close of the 15:55 bar29,813.50
Gap28 Oct 9:30 open 29,929.50up 116 pts (filter: 25 to 200)
Setup9:30 bar: high 29,952.75, low 29,887.25, gap still openshort 29,930.75
StopOne tick over the 9:30 high29,953.00 (22.25 pts, $44.50 per MNQ)
TargetThe prior close, 117.25 pts away, more than the stop29,813.50
Worst point9:35 bar high29,933.50, 2.75 pts against
Outcome9:45 bar traded to 29,770.25target: 117.25 × $2 = $234.50 per MNQ

Read the chart from left to right. The prior session closed at 29,813.50; overnight, price moved up, and the regular session opened 116 points higher. The first bar went both ways and closed almost where it opened, with the gap still open: a short. Price never came within 19.5 points of the stop and fell through the prior close on the third bar of the trade. Dollar figures are per micro contract, before commissions and slippage. Hypothetical: what the written rules would have done that day, not trades anyone placed (CFTC Rule 4.41 notice below the next example).

3. A session where the same rules failed

Real chartSelected example, chosen to show the rulesStopped

MNQ 5-minute chart, 5 October 2026 from 15:15 ET to 6 October 11:10 ET: the prior close at 31,338.25, a 9:30 open at 31,513.25, 175 points higher; the 9:30 bar closes at 31,487.00, a short there with the stop at 31,567.50; the 10:05 bar trades to 31,578.75 and hits the stop, and price keeps rising, far from the prior close
MNQ (Dec 2026) · 5-minute · 5–6 Oct 2026, ET · Chart: TradingView (snapshot; levels and labels marked by Tarrow Futures). A past session, selected to show the rules, not a typical result.
StepWhat the chart showsNumber
Prior close5 Oct, close of the 15:55 bar31,338.25
Gap6 Oct 9:30 open 31,513.25up 175 pts (filter: 25 to 200)
Setup9:30 bar: high 31,567.25, low 31,475.50, gap still openshort 31,487.00
StopOne tick over the 9:30 high31,567.50 (80.5 pts, $161 per MNQ)
TargetThe prior close, 148.75 pts away31,338.25
Best point9:35 bar low, the day's low31,457.50, 29.5 pts in favour
Outcome10:05 bar traded to 31,578.75stopped: 80.5 × $2 = −$161 per MNQ
The lesson: the first bar sets the stop, and some first bars are wide

The gap never filled that day. The session's lowest price, 31,457.50 on the 9:35 bar, stayed 119.25 points above the prior close, and price went on rising after the stop. A gap fill card is a bet against the opening move; on a day the opening move is the start of a trend, the card loses.

The stop was the bigger lesson. The first bar was 91.75 points tall, so the stop sat 80.5 points from the entry, against 22.25 on 28 October. Size from the stop: with $200 a trade (example budget), rule 11 gives $200 ÷ $161 = 1.24, rounded down to 1 MNQ, a $161 loss. A trader who kept the 4 MNQ that fit 28 October's stop would have lost 4 × $161 = $644 on one trade. Test any filter, such as a maximum first-bar size, on many sessions before trusting it.

CFTC Rule 4.41: Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record, simulated results do not represent actual trading. Also, since the trades have not been executed, the results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profit or losses similar to those shown.

4. How it fits prop firm rules

Daily loss limit: one trade, but its size changes every day

The card allows one trade a day, so the worst day is one stop. That stop is not fixed. Example figures: with $200 a trade, 28 October is $200 ÷ $44.50 = 4.49, so 4 MNQ ($178 at risk); 6 October is 1 MNQ ($161). Work out the contract count each morning from that day's first bar, after 9:35, not the night before.

Gaps cluster around news

A large gap can follow overnight news or an economic release before the open, such as the 8:30 ET jobs and CPI reports. Some firms restrict trading around scheduled releases; read prop firm news trading rules and check whether your firm's window covers 9:30 on a release day.

Consistency rule: one fast fill can be a large share of a quiet month

Example figures: at 1 MNQ, 28 October was $234.50. Under a consistency rule that caps your best day at half of total profit (example rule), that day needs total profit of at least $234.50 × 2 = $469 before it fits. Rules differ by firm; check yours.

Close-out time

The card's 12:00 ET exit is ours. If your firm sets its own time by which positions must be flat and it is earlier, it becomes the time exit. Check your firm's current rulebook.

5. Test it yourself before you trade it

  1. Write the card down exactly. Which close (the 16:00 ET close, the CME settlement or the 17:00 ET end of the futures day), the gap filter, what "traded back to the prior close" means, the stop and its minimum, the target rule and the time exit. If two people could code it differently, it is not finished.
  2. Backtest it on your contract, many sessions. Record every gap, its size, whether the first bar filled it, the stop distance, the worst price while open and the outcome. Record the gaps the card skipped too.
  3. Split the results by gap size. Small and large gaps may behave differently. Look at your own numbers before deciding where the filter's edges belong; don't take ours.
  4. Add costs. Commission both ways and slippage on every fill. The first minutes of the session move fast, so test the fill at the close of the 9:30 bar with a few ticks of slippage.
  5. Run your size through the rules. The widest first-bar stop you saw × your contract count against your daily limit, your best day against any consistency rule, then forward-test on a simulator for weeks before any paid evaluation.

Know a trader learning this strategy? Send them this breakdown. It's free for them too.

Disclosures

Education only. This page explains how a widely known, public strategy is defined and how you could test it yourself. It is not advice, not a recommendation to trade any contract, size or strategy, and not a signal: it shows no setup for any future session. Charts are real past sessions, chosen to show the rules (including a day they failed); they are selected examples, not typical results. The charts are TradingView snapshots (MNQ1!, regular trading hours, one-minute unless the caption says otherwise; a volume profile, where shown, is TradingView's built-in Fixed Range Volume Profile); diagrams labelled as illustrations are drawn by Tarrow Futures and are not market data. The level, range, entry, stop and target marks and labels on them were added by Tarrow Futures. Bars may differ slightly from those on your platform. Trade outcomes on this page are what the written rules would have done on those days, before commissions and slippage. They are not trades Tarrow Futures placed. Dollar figures for sequences and rules are example figures, not results. Prop firm rules differ and change; your firm's current rulebook decides. Futures trading involves substantial risk of loss. Automation does not remove risk.

CFTC Rule 4.41: Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record, simulated results do not represent actual trading. Also, since the trades have not been executed, the results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profit or losses similar to those shown.